Cochrane · intervention · CD001829

Interventions for treating oral leukoplakia to prevent oral cancer

Lodi, G, Franchini, R, Warnakulasuriya, S, et al. · Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews · 2016 · Cochrane Library

Oral HealthOral medicine and oral cancer4 versionsAMSTAR 2: not assessed
Full textEvery question was extracted from the full review (methods and results), not only its Summary of Findings table.
Questions
26
current version
GRADE rated
8
No studies
4
Included studies
14
as reported
No studies 4 · 15.4%Ungraded 14 · 53.8%Very low 5 · 19.2%Low 2 · 7.7%Moderate 1 · 3.8%High 0 · 0%

Ungraded means an effect was reported without a GRADE rating; it is not a gap. No studies means the review found nothing to answer the question. The six categories are a display order, not a score.

Review question

ElementPlanned (methods)Found (results)
PopulationAnyone with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia (without histopathological evidence of carcinoma) as defined, at the time of the studies, by consensus conferences held in 1978, 1983, 1994 and 2005People with oral leukoplakia (909 participants across 14 studies; mean 64.9, range 10 to 131); smoking 8 to 86%; drinking 9 to 71%; 2 studies only betel-quid chewers (India); dysplastic lesions 18.75 to 73.2% (7 studies)
InterventionSurgical removal of the lesion (surgical excision, laser surgery, cryotherapy); topical medical treatment (anti-inflammatory agents, antimycotic agents, carotenoids and retinoids, cytotoxic agents); systemic medical treatment; removal of predisposing habits (e.g. tobacco, alcohol); other treatment (e.g. photodynamic therapy); combined treatmentVitamin A or retinoids (n=4); beta carotene or carotenoids (n=3); NSAIDs - ketorolac and celecoxib (n=2); herbal extracts - tea components, Chinese herbal mixture, freeze-dried black raspberry gel (n=4); topical bleomycin (n=1); Bowman-Birk inhibitor (n=1)
ComparisonPlacebo; no treatmentPlacebo (n=14; one used a placebo containing vitamin C, Nagao 2015)
OutcomesOral cancer development demonstrated by histopathological examination (primary); clinical resolution (proportion of lesions not resolved, with relapse data); improvement of histological features; safety (incidence of adverse effects)Oral cancer development (n=5 reported, 3 usable); clinical resolution (n=13-14); improvement of histological features (n=6); safety/adverse effects (n=12)
Study designsRandomised controlled trials comparing surgery, medical or complementary treatment (local or systemic) or risk factor cessation versus placeboRCT (n=14; 10 two-arm, 3 three-arm, 1 four-arm parallel design)
TimingNot specifiedFollow-up: most studies less than 1 year; one lasted 2 years; three used open follow-up (up to 7 years)

Search date: 2016-05. Databases: Cochrane Oral Health's Trials Register; CENTRAL; MEDLINE Ovid; Embase Ovid; CancerLit via PubMed; metaRegister of Controlled Trials; ClinicalTrials.gov; WHO International Clinical Trials Registry Platform

Questions and results

Current version only

Vitamin A or retinoids (systemic or topical; incl. 13-cis-retinoic acid, acitretin) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB4 (current) · 4 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
4 to 12 months
SoF 1, Clinical resolution (not completely resolved) at 4 to 12 months: 'Studies could not be combined in meta-analysis. One study evaluated topical treatment and did not find evidence of benefit; 3 studies of systemic…4 studiesUngraded
Improvement of histological features (not improved)
3 months
RR 0.43 [0.24, 0.76]
889 per 1000 vs 382 per 1000
1 study · 41 participantsModerate
Downgraded: imprecision
Oral cancer development
24 months (treatment lasted 12 months)
RR 0.11 [0.01, 2.05]
93 per 1000 vs 10 per 1000
1 study · 85 participantsVery low
Downgraded: risk of bias, imprecision
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
4 to 12 months
SoF 1, Safety of the intervention at 4 to 12 months: '3 studies (1 each evaluating topical acitretin, topical 13-cis-retinoic acid, 200,000 IU per week of vitamin A) found no adverse effects. Systemic 13-cis-retinoic…4 studiesUngraded

Systemic beta carotene or carotenoids (incl. lycopene) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB4 (current) · 4 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Improvement of histological features (not improved)
5 months (treatment lasted 3 months)
RR 0.24 [0.12, 0.46]
833 per 1000 vs 200 per 1000
1 study · 58 participantsLow
Downgraded: risk of bias, imprecision
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
5 to 12 months
SoF 2, Safety of the intervention at 5 to 12 months: 'Systemic beta carotene did not cause any adverse effects in 1 study supplementing 10 mg/d (Nagao), and caused adverse effects of varying severity in 9% of…3 studiesUngraded
Oral cancer development
24 months
RR 0.71 [0.24, 2.09]
108 per 1000 vs 79 per 1000
2 studies · 132 participantsVery low
Downgraded: risk of bias, imprecision
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
5 to 12 months
SoF 2, Clinical resolution (not completely resolved) at 5 to 12 months: 'The 3 studies could not be combined in meta-analysis. 2 found benefit for systemic beta carotene, and 1 did not.' No GRADE rating. Effects text…3 studiesUngraded

Topical bleomycin vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB4 (current) · 4 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
3 months
RR 0.55 [0.29, 1.04]
917 per 1000 vs 504 per 1000
1 study · 22 participantsVery low
Downgraded: risk of bias, imprecision
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
up to 3 months
SoF 5, Safety of the intervention up to 3 months: 'All patients in the bleomycin group developed erythema with erosion by the end of the applications, whereas erythema developed in the placebo group. Discomfort was…1 studyUngraded
Oral cancer development
up to 7 years
RR 3.00 [0.32, 27.83]
83 per 1000 vs 250 per 1000
1 study · 20 participantsVery low
Downgraded: risk of bias, imprecision
Improvement of histological features (not improved)
3 months
RR 0.49 [0.22, 1.10]
818 per 1000 vs 401 per 1000
1 study · 21 participantsVery low
Downgraded: risk of bias, imprecision

Herbal extracts (tea components; Chinese herbal mixture; freeze-dried black raspberry gel) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB4 (current) · 4 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Oral cancer development
SoF 4 (Herbal extracts vs placebo), Cancer development: SoF cell 'Not measured'. Effects text: cancer development was among the outcomes in Tsao 2009 (green tea extract) but it was not possible to analyse the data…1 studyUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
3 to 6 months
SoF 4, Clinical resolution (not completely resolved) at 3 to 6 months: '3 studies (freeze-dried black raspberry gel, green tea extract capsules, mixed tea) did not find evidence of benefit.' No GRADE. Effects text:…4 studiesUngraded
Improvement of histological features (not improved)
3 months
SoF 4, Histological changes (not improved) at 3 months: '2 studies (green tea extract capsules and freeze-dried raspberry gel) did not find evidence of benefit.' No GRADE. Effects text: Mallery raspberry RR 0.97…2 studiesUngraded
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
up to 3 months
SoF 4, Safety of the intervention up to 3 months: '3 studies measured adverse effects: green tea extract capsules caused high frequency (93%) of adverse effects of varying severity in 1 study; the mixed tea study did…3 studiesUngraded

Surgical removal of the lesion (surgical excision, laser surgery, cryotherapy) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB4 (current) · 1 question
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Outcome NR
'We did not identify any RCTs that compared surgical treatments with placebo or no treatment.' Three surgical RCTs were found (Chee 2013, Lopez-Jornet 2013, Schwarz 2005) but all excluded because they did not include a…NRNo studies

Removal of predisposing habits (e.g. tobacco/alcohol cessation) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB4 (current) · 1 question
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Outcome NR
'...nor did we identify any RCTs of risk factor cessation.' Removal of predisposing habits (e.g. smoking cessation) was a planned intervention; no eligible RCT found.NRNo studies

NSAIDs (ketorolac oral rinse; systemic celecoxib) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB4 (current) · 4 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Improvement of histological features (not improved)
SoF 3, Histological changes: 'Not measured'. Effects text: 'Histological changes were not among the outcomes in the studies testing NSAIDs.'0 studiesNo studies
Oral cancer development
SoF 3 (NSAIDs vs placebo), Cancer development: SoF cell 'Not measured'. Effects text: cancer development was among outcomes in Papadimitrakopoulou 2008 (celecoxib) but did not occur in either arm, probably because of…1 studyUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
3 months
SoF 3, Clinical resolution (not completely resolved) at 3 months: '1 study evaluated systemic treatment and 1 evaluated topical treatment. Neither found benefit for NSAIDs.' No GRADE. Effects text: celecoxib…2 studiesUngraded
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
over 3 months
SoF 3, Safety of the intervention over 3 months: systemic celecoxib (1 study) - 32 intervention participants reported 56 adverse effects, 20 placebo participants reported 20; 4 grade 3 events; 2 discontinued. Ketorolac…2 studiesUngraded

Bowman-Birk inhibitor vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB4 (current) · 4 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Improvement of histological features (not improved)
SoF 6, Histological changes: 'Not measured'. Effects text: data on histological changes from Armstrong 2013 were not available for analysis, but study authors reported no statistically significant differences in…1 studyUngraded
Oral cancer development
SoF 6 (Bowman-Birk inhibitor vs placebo), Cancer development: 'Not measured'. Effects text: 'Cancer development was not among the outcomes of the study testing the Bowman-Birk inhibitor (Armstrong 2013).'0 studiesNo studies
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
6 months
RR 1.00 [0.91, 1.09]
957 per 1000 vs 957 per 1000
1 study · 21 participantsLow
Downgraded: risk of bias, imprecision
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
up to 6 months
SoF 6, Safety of the intervention up to 6 months: 'Trial authors reported that there were no significant adverse effects. 33 participants in the intervention group reported 75 adverse effects. 25 participants in the…1 studyUngraded

Vitamin A or retinoids (systemic or topical; incl. 13-cis-retinoic acid, acitretin) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB3 · 4 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
Adverse effects (Table 1): systemic 13-cis-retinoic acid 79%; vitamin A 300,000 IU/wk 26%; topical acitretin (Gaeta), topical 13-cis-retinoic acid (Piattelli), vitamin A 200,000 IU/wk (Stich) no adverse effects.5 studiesUngraded
Malignant transformation (oral cancer development)
Malignant transformation (Comparison 1, Outcome 1.1), systemic vitamin A (Sankaranarayan 1997): not estimable; none of the treatments showed benefit vs placebo (2 studies, 172 participants).1 studyUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
RR 0.69 [0.50, 0.96]5 studies · 245 participantsUngraded
Histological worsening (variation in histological features)
RR 0.51 [0.32, 0.81]1 studyUngraded

Systemic beta carotene or carotenoids (incl. lycopene) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB3 · 4 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
Adverse effects (Table 1): beta carotene 360 mg/wk 9%; lycopene 8 or 4 mg (Singh) 0/40 vs 0/18, no adverse effects.2 studiesUngraded
Histological worsening (variation in histological features)
RR 0.24 [0.12, 0.46]1 study · 58 participantsUngraded
Malignant transformation (oral cancer development)
Malignant transformation (Comparison 1, Outcome 1.1), systemic beta carotene (Sankaranarayan 1997): not estimable; no benefit vs placebo.1 studyUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
RR 0.69 [0.54, 0.88]2 studies · 168 participantsUngraded

Topical bleomycin vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB3 · 4 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
RR 0.55 [0.29, 1.04]1 study · 22 participantsUngraded
Malignant transformation (oral cancer development)
Malignant transformation (Comparison 1, Outcome 1.1), topical bleomycin (Epstein 1994): not estimable; no benefit vs placebo.1 studyUngraded
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
Adverse effects (Table 1): topical bleomycin 10/10 vs 0/12 (100%).1 studyUngraded
Histological worsening (variation in histological features)
Histological changes, topical bleomycin (Epstein 1994): assessed; no significant benefit; no pooled estimate reported.1 studyUngraded

Mixed tea (green tea extract, polyphenols and pigments; topical plus systemic) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB3 · 2 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
Adverse effects (Table 1): systemic and topical tea (Li) 0/32 vs 0/32; no adverse effects.1 studyUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
RR 1.0 [0.94, 1.06]1 study · 64 participantsUngraded

Surgical removal of the lesion (surgical excision, laser surgery, cryotherapy) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB3 · 1 question
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Outcome NR
Description of studies: one RCT evaluating surgical interventions was found (Schwarz 2005) but excluded because it did not include a no-treatment/placebo group; no eligible surgical RCT.NRNo studies

Removal of predisposing habits (e.g. tobacco/alcohol cessation) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB3 · 1 question
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Outcome NR
Removal of predisposing habits (risk factor cessation) was a planned intervention; no eligible RCT found.NRNo studies

NSAID (ketorolac oral rinse) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB3 · 2 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
Adverse effects (Table 1): ketorolac oral rinse (Mulshine) 11/38 vs 3/19 (29%); pain, toxicity grade 1 and 2; one withdrawal after first dose due to mouth pain.1 studyUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
Clinical resolution (Comparison 1, Outcome 1.2), ketorolac oral rinse (Mulshine 2004): assessed as a single study, showed no benefit vs placebo (grouped with bleomycin and tea as single-study treatments).1 studyUngraded

Vitamin A or retinoids (systemic or topical; incl. 13-cis-retinoic acid, acitretin) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB2 · 4 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
Adverse effects (Table 1): systemic 13-cis-retinoic acid 79%; vitamin A 300,000 IU/wk 26%; topical acitretin (Gaeta) 0/14 vs 0/7 no AEs; topical 13-cis-retinoic acid (Piattelli) 0/5; vitamin A 200,000 IU/wk (Stich) 0/30.5 studiesUngraded
Histological worsening (variation in histological features)
RR 0.51 [0.32, 0.81]1 studyUngraded
Malignant transformation (oral cancer development)
Malignant transformation (Comparison 01, Outcome 01), systemic vitamin A (Sankaranarayan 1997): not estimable; none of the treatments showed benefit vs placebo (2 studies, 227 participants).1 studyUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
RR 0.69 [0.50, 0.96]5 studies · 245 participantsUngraded

Systemic beta carotene or carotenoids (incl. lycopene) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB2 · 3 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
Adverse effects (Table 1): beta carotene 360 mg/wk 5/55 vs 1/55 (9%).1 studyUngraded
Malignant transformation (oral cancer development)
Malignant transformation (Comparison 01, Outcome 01), systemic beta carotene (Sankaranarayan 1997): not estimable; no benefit vs placebo.1 studyUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
RR 0.77 [0.65, 0.92]1 study · 110 participantsUngraded

Topical bleomycin vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB2 · 4 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
Adverse effects (Table 1): topical bleomycin 10/10 vs 0/12 (100%).1 studyUngraded
Malignant transformation (oral cancer development)
Malignant transformation (Comparison 01, Outcome 01), topical bleomycin (Epstein 1994): not estimable; no benefit vs placebo.1 studyUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
RR 0.55 [0.29, 1.04]1 study · 22 participantsUngraded
Histological worsening (variation in histological features)
Histological changes, topical bleomycin (Epstein 1994): worsened more often with placebo but difference not significant; no pooled estimate reported.1 studyUngraded

Mixed tea (green tea extract, polyphenols and pigments; topical plus systemic) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB2 · 2 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
Adverse effects (Table 1): systemic and topical tea (Li) 0/32 vs 0/32; no adverse effects.1 studyUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
RR 1.0 [0.94, 1.06]1 study · 64 participantsUngraded

Surgical removal of the lesion (surgical excision, laser surgery, cryotherapy) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB2 · 1 question
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Outcome NR
Description of studies: 'We found no randomised controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating surgical interventions.' Surgery vs no treatment/placebo not studied in any eligible RCT.NRNo studies

Removal of predisposing habits (e.g. tobacco/alcohol cessation) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829.PUB2 · 1 question
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Outcome NR
Removal of predisposing habits (e.g. tobacco/alcohol cessation) was a planned intervention; no eligible RCT of risk factor cessation was found.NRNo studies

Vitamin A or retinoids (systemic or topical; incl. 13-cis-retinoic acid, acitretin) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829 · 4 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
Adverse effects (Table 1): systemic 13-cis-retinoic acid (Hong) 19/24 vs 4/20 (79%); vitamin A 300,000 IU/wk (Sankaranarayan) 13/50 vs 1/55 (26%); topical 13-cis-retinoic acid (Piattelli) 0/5 vs 0/5; vitamin A 200,000…4 studiesUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
RR 0.72 [0.52, 1.01]4 studies · 224 participantsUngraded
Histological worsening (variation in histological features)
RR 0.51 [0.32, 0.81]1 studyUngraded
Malignant transformation (oral cancer development)
Malignant transformation (Comparison 1, Outcome 1.1), systemic vitamin A subgroup (Sankaranarayan 1997): not estimable (RevMan RR 0.0 [0.0, 0.0], totals not selected); none of the treatments showed benefit vs placebo…1 studyUngraded

Systemic beta carotene or carotenoids (incl. lycopene) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829 · 3 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
Adverse effects (Table 1): beta carotene 360 mg/wk (Sankaranarayan) 5/55 vs 1/55 (9%).1 studyUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
RR 0.77 [0.65, 0.92]1 study · 110 participantsUngraded
Malignant transformation (oral cancer development)
Malignant transformation (Comparison 1, Outcome 1.1), systemic beta carotene subgroup (Sankaranarayan 1997): not estimable (RevMan RR 0.0 [0.0, 0.0], totals not selected); no benefit vs placebo.1 studyUngraded

Topical bleomycin vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829 · 4 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
Adverse effects (Table 1): topical bleomycin (Epstein) 10/10 vs 0/12 (100%).1 studyUngraded
Malignant transformation (oral cancer development)
Malignant transformation (Comparison 1, Outcome 1.1), topical bleomycin subgroup (Epstein 1994): not estimable (RevMan RR 0.0 [0.0, 0.0], totals not selected); no benefit vs placebo.1 studyUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
RR 0.55 [0.29, 1.04]1 study · 22 participantsUngraded
Histological worsening (variation in histological features)
Histological worsening (Comparison 1, Outcome 1.3), topical bleomycin (Epstein 1994): histological aspect worsened more often with placebo but difference not significant; no pooled estimate reported (totals not…1 studyUngraded

Mixed tea (green tea extract, polyphenols and pigments; topical plus systemic) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829 · 2 questions
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Safety of the intervention (adverse effects)
Adverse effects (Table 1): systemic and topical tea (Li) 0/32 vs 0/32; no adverse effects.1 studyUngraded
Clinical resolution (oral lesion not completely resolved)
RR 1.0 [0.94, 1.06]1 study · 64 participantsUngraded

Surgical removal of the lesion (surgical excision, laser surgery, cryotherapy) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829 · 1 question
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Outcome NR
Description of studies: 'We found no RCTs evaluating surgical interventions.' Surgical treatment (excision, laser, cryotherapy) versus no treatment/placebo not studied in any RCT.NRNo studies

Removal of predisposing habits (e.g. tobacco/alcohol cessation) vs Placebo or no treatment

Population: People with a diagnosis of oral leukoplakia
CD001829 · 1 question
OutcomeEffectEvidenceStatus / GRADE
Outcome NR
Discussion: 'Trials evaluating interventions directed against risk factors (i.e. smoking) are also missing.' Removal of predisposing habits was a planned intervention but no eligible RCT was found.NRNo studies